[asdf-devel] Make the CL syntax predictable

[Attila Lendvai]

> That's why, for example, we have systems that bleed readtable across
> their boundaries: the systems really aren't stand alone entities, but
> limitations on ASDF expressiveness, and the desire to get more
> modularity than the (necessarily in-line) :MODULE will permit, causes a
> proliferation of systems that are NOT libraries, and have meaning only
> in context.
>
> I'm not going to move ASDF towards breaking such systems.


Robert, this is how i see it reading this thread:

 - you know at least about one big and complex codebase with many asdf
   systems, where isolating *readtable* would break it and cause a lot
   of work/headache that is hard to debug, especially if the codebase
   doesn't compile free of warnings to begin with. this headache would
   probably be yours in case of this system.

 - to Fare (and to me, who have wasted precious hours due to this)
   readtable higiene clearly looks like a major improvement when
   looking at it objectively, so much so that somewhere down the road
   breaking systems that now break other systems (by modifying the
   global readtable) is acceptable. my impression is that you would
   also agree with this if the legacy was not pulling your back.

*if* this is the case, then why not accommodate for such legacy
systems/use-cases simply by e.g.:

;; force upgrade
(asdf:load-system :asdf)

;; optionally, for extra safety
(asdf:load-all-dependencies-of :my-legacy-system)

(setf asdf:*readtable-higiene* nil)

(asdf:load-system :my-legacy-system)

and then we can have our cake and eat it too...

(alternatively a new system class could be introduced and all legacy
systems could specify a :class "hu.dwim.asdf:hu.dwim.system", just
like we need to do currently for self-defense purposes against
e.g. readtable polluters and against we polluting the readtables.)

-- 
• attila lendvai
• PGP: 963F 5D5F 45C7 DFCD 0A39
--
“I maintain that Truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it
by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. [...] The moment
you follow someone you cease to follow Truth.”
	— Jiddu Krishnamurti (1901–1986)