[cl-debian] Bug#434812: cl-sql: not binNMU safe

Kevin Rosenberg kevin at rosenberg.net
Fri Jul 27 08:26:00 UTC 2007


Lior Kaplan wrote:
> That's understood. Please use the example at
> http://lintian.debian.org/reports/Tnot-binnmuable-all-depends-any.html
> to solve the problem you mentioned.

Thanks for the link. But, I don't see how the solves the issue. It
still declares the dependent package can depend upon a newer version
of the any package when no such guarantee of compatibility exists in
the upstream source.

> Don't forget you might cause your package to be uninstallable with the
> tight dependencies. That might be even less nice than have compatibility
> problems.

I'd perfer the package be uninstallable than have an incompatible set
of binary packages installed.  To my mind, that's part of the
advantage of the debian packaging system, to reduce the possibility of
incompatible packages being installed.

-- 
Kevin Rosenberg
kevin at hypershots.com






More information about the Cl-debian mailing list