[armedbear-devel] CLOS / D-M-C tests failure DMC-TEST-MC.1 help requested

[Rudolf Schlatte]

On Aug 7, 2012, at 20:41, Erik Huelsmann <ehuels at gmail.com> wrote:

[...]

> So, just to show the code that's failing to be correctly compiled:
> 
> Form 1:
> (define-method-combination dmc-test-args-with-optional.4 ()
>   ((methods ()))
>   (:arguments &optional (a :default sup-p))
>   `(progn ,@(mapcar (lambda (method) `(call-method ,method))
>                     methods)
>           (values ,a ,sup-p)))
> 
> Form 2:
> (defgeneric dmc-test-args-with-optional.4a (x &optional b)
>   (:method-combination dmc-test-args-with-optional.4)
>   (:method (x &optional b) (progn x b)))
> 
> 
> My compilation steps are to go into Form 1 and hit C-c C-c. Then do the same with Form 2.
> 
> Every time when I do that, the method combination of the generic function comes out with #<METHOD-COMBINATION STANDARD>. Which is clearly wrong.

After fixing Stas's bug report (missing :method-combination initarg for standard-generic-functions), following this recipe gets me the right method combination.  Can you re-check as well?

Thanks,

Rudi